The Giver

Wow. The Giver certainly does not suffer from the Tom Sawyer effect. I just re-read The Giver after reading it at age 10.

I realize a lot has changed since I was in fifth grade, and I certainly hope that I've matured A LOT since that time.

However, I found the book to be thought-provoking and extremely riveting. It still resonates with me--I can't stop thinking about it. I can't wait for the seminar to hear my classmates' opinions and thoughts on the text. I want to ask a few questions:

-Is The Giver's Rosemary the same Rosemary as the one who was chosen to be the next Receiver? Does he mean "be with her" in Heaven or is she still alive somehow? Is is possible that she a "real" daughter, not just a "family unit" daughter?

-How is Jonas able to experience the snow/sled/Christmas memories as his own--they were transmitted to him and I don't get that. Were they premonitions instead of memories?

I have to read Gathering Blue and The Messenger, though they're apparently not sequels. Still, I'm sure they're amazing.

Mark Twain

How would Twain define morality?

Thinking about this question after reading Tom Sawyer and listening to Engel's lecture on Twain's life, I think Twain's definition of morality would include acting for the good of humanity but still having fun. I don't think Twain was Kantian in his ethical makeup--Tom's "white lies" and devious behavior throughout the book certainly don't reflect a universal law mentality.

I think Tom envelops many of Twain's own characteristics--for example, Twain's dislike of high society is mirrored in the character Huck Finn. Similarly, Tom's view of morality is probably pretty similar to Twain's. Though many of Tom's antics are less than moral, he still does the right thing when necessary. For example Tom defends Muff Potter during the murder trial, even though Tom is scared of Injun Joe's reaction. Tom also comes to Becky's rescue over the ripped anatomy book and takes the punishment for her. Tom lies to Aunt Polly on several occasions, but never in a dire situation.

I think Twain would describe morality as doing the right thing when it counts and treating everyone with respect. Being of genuinely good moral character and acting selflessly, I believe, would be part of Twain's definition.

What's up with Tom Sawyer?

I remember devouring Mark Twain short stories and loving Tom Sawyer when I was little. This time around, I'm having a difficult time getting interested in the text. I feel so disconnected from Tom's world. I simply cannot relate to a young boy who tricks his friends into whitewashing his fence, who tortures bugs during church, and who steals rafts and turns into a "pirate" with his best buds. My life is too different from his to relate on any level. It's not that I don't appreciate Twain's imagination or his writing style; I'm just not invested in the book.

I didn't have the same problem with either The Graveyard Book or The Trumpet of the Swan. It's not that my life parallels a boy who's growing up in a graveyard or a literate, musical swan, but somehow these books kept my interest far better than Tom Sawyer has.

As I stare at the pile of YA books on my desk, I can't help but wish that we were reading The Giver or The Phantom Tollbooth, both childhood favorites of mine. I remember themes in both of those that I believe will still be applicable to me today, ten years after my initial reading of the texts.

This class is teaching me that perspective really changes one's outlook on anything that person reads--for better or for worse!

Scarlet Ibis pt. 2

What was the most human or universal sentiment expressed in this short story?

-I think love was easily the most universal sentiment. The first example I thought of was when Doodle walked for the first time and his family gathered around, hugging and crying and smiling. Aunt Nicey loved Doodle from the beginning because "he was born in a caul, and cauls were made from Jesus' nightgown." More examples of love include Doodle and the fallen Ibis (I think Doodle was fascinated and drawn to the unique animal and felt an unusual kinship with it) and the brotherly love between Brother and Doodle as they spent time together and came to love each other even though Doodle wasn't the "ideal brother" that Brother was expecting.